A sermon may repeatedly proclaim that “Christ died for our sins” and yet fail to make hearers understand why they need such a death. This is the central weakness of the Clifton Hill Presbyterian Church Easter Sunday sermon on 1 Corinthians 15 preached by Rev Bill Medley. It affirms Paul’s claim that Christ’s death and resurrection are matters “of first importance.” It rightly insists that the resurrection is a real event in history, not a religious symbol or merely private experience. Yet its lengthy defense of the resurrection does not adequately answer the more urgent question: Why must a sinner have a crucified and risen Saviour?
This central weakness goes beyond giving too much space to an apologetic argument. Its deeper defect is theological and experiential: it proclaims that Christ “died for our sins” without explaining the sinner’s condition in Adam, and it calls for repentance without explaining the necessity of the new birth. These concerns are central to the events of Easter.
The sermon speaks of sin principally as what people have “done, thought and said.” It describes the hearer as a rebel who has lived “my own way” and must remove “the kingship” of self in order to place Christ in that position. True, sin does include actual transgressions, self-rule, and rebellion against God. But they are not yet an adequate account of why a person needs the death and resurrection of Christ.
The sermon never opens the deeper biblical diagnosis: humanity is not merely made up of individuals who have accumulated sinful acts. In Adam, humanity stands guilty, fallen, corrupt, and spiritually unable to return to God. Original sin is not a speculative doctrine added to the gospel from outside. It explains why the gospel is such good news.
Nowhere does Scripture present sinners as morally neutral people who have made poor choices and must now make a better one. It presents them as dead in transgressions and sin, following the course of a fallen world, living according to the desires of the flesh, and by nature children of wrath (Ephesians 2:1–3). David confesses not only the particular evil he had done, but that he was brought forth in iniquity and conceived in sin (Psalm 51:5). Paul explains that sin and death entered the world through one man, Adam, and that condemnation came upon all through his trespass (Romans 5:12–19).
This is the missing foundation in this sermon and most others in this Series. We sin because we are sinners. We do not become sinners merely by committing individual sins. The fall has affected the whole person: mind, will, desires, conscience, and affections. A sinner may know that God exists, may hear the historical arguments for the resurrection, may fear judgment, may resolve to do better, and may even outwardly attach himself to a church, while remaining spiritually dead.
The sermon’s appeal does not adequately reckon with that reality. It tells the hearer to humble himself, confess his sins, and place Christ on the throne. But how will a sinner do this? How can one who is dead in sin willingly yield to Christ’s lordship? What changes the heart that loves self-rule and resists the light?
The answer is not found in a more forceful apologetic of historical evidence. It is the sovereign and gracious work of the Holy Spirit.
Jesus did not tell Nicodemus that he merely needed better evidence, greater seriousness, or a renewed moral resolve. He said, “You must be born again” (John 3:7). The new birth is God’s work. By the Spirit, He gives life to those dead in sin, opens blind eyes, removes the heart of stone, and grants repentance and faith. Regeneration does not mean that a person first decides to become a Christian and is then made alive. It means that God makes the sinner alive, and the sinner therefore comes to Christ in faith.
This distinction is essential. Now, conversion is not mentioned in this sermon and without it, the resurrection has become an opportunity for self-reformation: a person recognizes that he has ruled his own life, decides to dethrone himself, and makes Jesus Lord. But that is not the biblical gospel. Christ is already Lord. The sinner does not make Him Lord by an act of decision. Rather, through the new birth, the sinner is brought to see Christ as Lord and Saviour, to hate his sin, to abandon self-righteousness, and to receive and rest upon Christ alone.
The sermon criticizes faith built on subjective experiences, miracles, or answered prayer. That warning has value. Christian faith is not grounded in fluctuating religious feelings. But the sermon risks replacing subjective experience with bare assent to an historical event. A man can be persuaded that Christ rose from the dead and remain unconverted. James warns that even the demons believe that God is one—and shudder (James 2:19). Belief in the historical resurrection is necessary, but it is not sufficient. Saving faith receives the crucified and risen Christ as He is freely offered in the gospel.
These omissions also weaken the sermon’s treatment of the resurrection. Christ’s resurrection is not simply proof that an extraordinary event occurred. He is the firstfruits of those who have fallen asleep (1 Corinthians 15:20). His resurrection is the beginning of the new creation. Those united to Him by the Spirit have been raised spiritually already and will be raised bodily at His return.
The question, therefore, is not simply, “Did Jesus rise?” It is also, “Have you been made alive with Christ?” The risen Christ does not merely offer encouragement to morally serious people. He gives life to the dead. He does not simply improve the old humanity in Adam; He creates a new humanity in Himself.
That is why the doctrine of original sin and the necessity of the new birth cannot be absent from an evangelistic resurrection sermon. Without original sin, the hearer may think he needs only forgiveness for isolated failures. Without regeneration, he may think he can save himself by a sufficiently sincere decision. But the gospel announces something far greater: sinners dead in Adam need the crucified and risen Christ to pardon their guilt, break sin’s dominion, and make them alive by His Spirit. This sermon is just another one in The New Birth in Exile series that presents a veneer of Christian terms, and yet fails to adequately diagnose their correct use.